Running a mental health practice isn’t just about providing excellent clinical care. Providers also face business decisions that affect patient access, financial sustainability, and the overall reputation of the practice. One of the trickiest areas is how to handle sliding scales and discounts.

These tools can make care more accessible, but they also raise important questions: How do you set fair policies? How do you prevent financial strain? And how do you communicate discounts without devaluing your services?

In this post, we’ll explore why providers use sliding scales, the difference between sliding scales and other discounts, and how to structure policies that are ethical, consistent, and sustainable.

Why Mental Health Providers Offer Sliding Scale Fees and Discounts

Providers reduce fees for several reasons, and at the heart of it is the tension between access and sustainability.

Access to care

Weekly therapy at full cash price can cost thousands of dollars a year, which is an impossible amount for many families. Sliding scales and discounts open the door to patients who otherwise couldn’t afford consistent treatment.

Ethical responsibility

Most clinicians don’t enter this field for the money. They want to help people, and reduced fees allow them to live that mission by serving a wider population.

Alternative to insurance

More than half of mental health providers don’t take insurance because of administrative burdens, low reimbursement, or both. For these practices, discounts are one of the only ways to make care feasible for cash-paying patients.

Special circumstances

Discounts can acknowledge unique hardships. A family that lost income, a student without outside support, or a Medicaid patient who otherwise couldn’t pay. Each may be able to stay in treatment thanks to thoughtful discounting.

Business sustainability with compassion

Discounts don’t have to undermine the practice. By allocating a specific portion of profits (e.g., 10%) to reduced-fee services, providers can give back while keeping the business financially sound.

Sliding Scale Fees vs. Other Types of Discounts

It’s easy to lump all discounts together, but the distinction matters.

A sliding scale adjusts rates based on income. The less a patient earns, the more their fee is reduced, usually with reference to federal poverty guidelines. For example, a family at 100% of the poverty line may pay only 10% of the usual rate, while those above 400% may not qualify for any discount.

Other types of discounts aren’t tied to income at all. They may be:

Automatic reductions for Medicaid patients or those with out-of-network insurance.
Family discounts, such as reduced rates when multiple siblings are seen in the same practice.
Referral credits as a way of thanking patients for word-of-mouth growth.
Incentives tied to scheduling, like lower fees for early morning slots.

The takeaway

Sliding scales are one type of discount, but not all discounts are sliding scales. Sliding scales require financial documentation and fairness checks, while other discounts are situational and based on practice policy.

How to Decide the Right Amount to Discount

Even when motivated by generosity, providers have to ask: Can I afford this?

It’s not uncommon for clinicians to overextend early in their careers, giving steep discounts to many patients. The result? Burnout, financial stress, or even the closure of their practice. That helps no one.

A healthier approach is to decide on a percentage of profit to dedicate to discounts. For instance, if a practice earns $5,000 profit per month, allocating 10% ($500) to reduced-fee services provides a safety net for patients without putting the practice at risk.

This method has two benefits:

Clarity: You know exactly how much you can give each month.
Boundaries: Once the pool is used, you can confidently say no without guilt, because it’s about business viability, not unwillingness to help.

Ethical and Legal Considerations for Discounting Therapy

Good intentions aren’t enough. Providers must be mindful of ethics and the law.

Consistency is key

Discounts can’t be given out informally to patients you “like” more. That opens the door to favoritism or discrimination claims.

Insurance rules apply

If you’re in-network with an insurer, you can’t legally reduce a patient’s copay or coinsurance unless it’s part of a documented, global policy.

Documentation protects you

A paper trail (whether through a letter or form) shows the discount was requested and applied according to policy.

Time limits matter

Discounts should be temporary (e.g., reviewed annually). This keeps you from making open-ended commitments you can’t sustain.

Without these safeguards, even a well-meaning discount policy can backfire financially, legally, or reputationally.

Communicating Sliding Scale and Discount Policies to Patients

Transparency helps patients feel respected and prevents misunderstandings, but how visible your policy should be is a business decision.

Some providers advertise sliding scales directly on their websites or Psychology Today profiles to attract patients. Others keep policies less public, only mentioning them in intake paperwork or discussing them when patients ask.

Either way, best practices include:

Having a written policy you can point to shows the discount isn’t arbitrary.
Requiring patients to formally request a discount, creating a record for your files.
Setting clear boundaries. Discounts might be temporary, tied to Medicaid, or limited to a set number of patients at a time.

This balance of visibility and structure ensures patients know help is available, while also reinforcing that your services have value.

Deciding Who Qualifies for Sliding Scale Fees and Discounts

Determining eligibility is one of the hardest parts.

Formal sliding scales use federal poverty guidelines, which divide households into income brackets (100%, 200%, 300%, 400%). Discounts are assigned to each bracket. But this approach requires verifying income through W-2s, tax returns, or pay stubs—processes that can feel invasive and still miss assets like savings or investments.

Because of this, many providers instead adopt simpler policies: automatic discounts for Medicaid patients, students, or those without insurance. These options are easier to manage, require less paperwork, and avoid the perception of arbitrary favoritism.

Ultimately, fairness comes from clarity and consistency. If you create a policy, every patient who meets the criteria should qualify. Avoid ad-hoc decisions that may feel compassionate in the moment but create legal or ethical problems down the line.

Mental Health Business Moment of the Week

In this week’s business moment, Tom told a story about how he tried to credential new providers at his clinic with an insurance company, only to have the entire application rejected because one date was entered incorrectly.

Instead of allowing a quick correction, the insurer required the whole process to start over. It was a frustrating example of how administrative barriers can slow down patient care and add unnecessary stress for clinics working to expand their services.

Conclusion: Discounts Done Right

Sliding scales and discounts are powerful tools, but only when handled thoughtfully. They make care more accessible, align with the values of mental health providers, and can even be used strategically to strengthen a practice’s reputation.

At the same time, they require clear boundaries. By setting policies in writing, documenting requests, and limiting discounts to what the business can sustain, providers can strike the right balance between compassion and sustainability.

Discounts done right not only support patients but also protect the long-term health of your practice.

Have a question or topic you’d like us to explore? Contact us at sitandstay@ripsytech.com.

And don’t forget to subscribe to the Sit and Stay Podcast for more insights on running a thriving mental health practice.

Looking for a health record solution that simplifies your workflows and supports your practice’s business needs?

RipsyTech has your back. Schedule a demo with us today.

Sliding Scale and Discounts in Private Mental Health Practice